Amir GanjavieIn Le Petit Dernier (The Little Sister), Hafsia Herzi adapts Fatima Daas’s autofictional novel into a cinematic portrait of queer adolescence within an Islamic cultural setting. The result is a film filled with promise, offering a rare glimpse into a life lived at the crossroads of desire, faith, and familial expectation—but one that, for all its potential, never quite excavates the emotional and political depths that lie beneath its surface.
The story centers on Fatima (Nadia Melliti), the youngest daughter in a Franco-Algerian household, living in the Parisian suburbs. She is a bright, physically strong, and reserved teen whose love for football, literature, and freestyling collides with her slowly awakening desire for women. She hides her sexuality beneath a deadpan gaze and a baseball cap, navigating a secular, Westernized adolescence while remaining tethered—at least symbolically—to Islamic rituals and familial codes.
Herzi approaches Fatima’s internal conflict with a quiet, observational style, staging her character’s sexual awakening with sensitivity. There’s real tenderness in the relationship that emerges between Fatima and Ji-Na (Park Ji-min), a Korean-French nurse. Their love, filled with stolen glances and vulnerable moments, echoes the intensity of first queer encounters—raw, unpredictable, and always on the verge of collapse. But the film falters in convincing us that this relationship is truly transformative. Ji-Na’s emotional unraveling feels underdeveloped, and her sudden reappearances are more plot devices than profound reckonings.
What Le Petit Dernier captures well is the adolescent experience of emotional fragmentation—the feeling of being stretched between identities, loyalties, and unknown futures. Melliti’s performance is carefully restrained; her silence often says more than dialogue could. And when she breaks—whether in the presence of an imam, a lover, or her own solitude—it is genuinely affecting. Herzi, to her credit, avoids sensationalism. She does not exoticize Fatima’s Muslim upbringing, nor does she demonize it. But perhaps in avoiding the clichés, she also avoids the conflicts. The religious backdrop, while omnipresent, often feels more atmospheric than transformative. We’re told of a culture of constraint, but rarely shown how it pierces the heart of the character.
The film’s most potent sequence—a veiled “confession” scene in the imam’s office—hints at the philosophical and spiritual dilemma that Fatima wrestles with. Yet these moments remain isolated, never quite integrated into a broader arc of reckoning. Fatima’s desire to remain a “good daughter” while pursuing a forbidden love should have created unbearable tension, but the film seems reluctant to turn that screw.
Herzi’s direction is gentle and intelligent, drawing on neorealist roots and a strong visual language—particularly in the film’s use of seasons to chart Fatima’s evolution. The decision to split the film into five chapters adds a lyrical rhythm but also fragments the emotional continuity. Some pivotal scenes—especially in the final act—carry more weight than the narrative has earned.
In the end, Le Petit Dernier is a film of moments rather than a fully realized whole. It offers glimpses of insight into what it means to grow up queer and Muslim, but those glimpses never quite congeal into the crisis or catharsis that the premise seems to promise. The emotional and spiritual stakes remain mostly implied rather than embodied.
Still, this is a tender, necessary film. It opens a door, even if it hesitates to walk fully through. And for many viewers, especially those navigating overlapping margins of identity, Le Petit Dernier will feel like a quiet affirmation. Herzi and Melliti, despite the film’s limits, have offered something rare: a portrait of queer adolescence not as a spectacle of tragedy or rebellion, but as a slow, subtle act of becoming.
© 2020-2025. UniversalCinema Mag.
